How to Decide if Coaching is Right for You
If my LinkedIn inbox is a representative sample of the coaching industry, there is a coach for virtually every facet of personal and professional life. But does that mean you actually need one?
Maybe. Maybe not.
As a coach who has also hired coaches, I know firsthand that the experience can be transformational—and I know it isn’t always worth the money. Sometimes that comes down to the quality of the coach. More often, though, it comes down to clarity: defining what success looks like, setting reasonable expectations upfront and knowing what is actually possible to achieve.
If you’re trying to decide whether coaching is your best next step, here is a framework to help you navigate the decision—and set yourself up for real, measurable progress.
What is coaching for?
Depending on your goals and who you work with, coaching usually operates across three distinct modes:
- Execution (Skill & Strategy): Coaching can help you learn and apply a new skill from someone with relevant experience. They observe your current work, spot your blockers, and help you outline concrete goals and action plans. When most people think about hiring a coach, this is what they imagine.
- Exploration (Self-Awareness): Most of us contribute to the very circumstances blocking our progress without realizing it. The "Explore" mode uncovers these hidden dynamics. It helps you look inward, see how you subconsciously respond to pressure or conflict, and gives you tools to make deliberate, different choices.
- Expansion (Mindset & Horizon): Often, people seek coaching at pivotal moments of transition. Even when framed as wanting to break into a new role or lead a team through a reorg, the deeper goal is to reframe who they are and what they can achieve. Coaching helps identify and dissolve limiting beliefs so you can see a broader horizon of possibility.
Knowing what will help is tricky
Most people enter coaching expecting pure execution. They think: "What I’m doing right now isn't working, so I want to hire a coach to fix it."
However, focusing only on execution almost never works long-term. If you don't explore the mindsets driving your old habits, or expand your perspective on what's possible, the same execution plan will keep stalling out.
What coaching can’t do
An ethical practitioner should be just as clear about what coaching cannot do. Coaching is not a cure-all, and it shouldn't be confused with other modalities:
- It won't give you a plug-and-play playbook: If you need a domain expert to hand you exact step-by-step technical instructions, you need a consultant or a mentor, not a coach.
- It won't fix a broken system: Coaching helps you change your own behavior and thinking. That can help repair the parts of an organization you have influence over, but unless you are a founder or otherwise have access to organization-wide power it is unlikely to fix deeply rooted organizational issues.
- It isn't therapy: Coaching focuses on present awareness and future action. If deep psychological distress or unhealed trauma is impacting your daily well-being, working with a licensed therapist is the appropriate and safest path.
Why coaching sometimes feels disappointing
Disappointment is almost always a function of unmet expectations. Even when real internal growth happens, you might feel like you aren't getting anywhere due to three common optical illusions in human development:
Distance to the goal
Coaching provides an objective mirror. Sometimes, a coach helps you realize you are much closer to your goal than you thought—which feels great. Other times, coaching reveals that the distance is much greater than you assumed, or that the path you’re on won't get you there.
In that moment, you’ve actually made massive progress by gaining an accurate map. But because the finish line now looks farther away, it can feel disheartening.
System delays
Growth rarely produces instant external feedback. Coaching often involves doing subtle, internal alignment work—rewiring how you process feedback or handle conflict—that takes time to manifest in your day-to-day life.
You might wrap up a coaching relationship feeling like you're in the exact same place, only to realize six months later that you're operating with a totally new level of ease.
The path of progress is a spiral
We want progress to be a straight, ascending line, but real development looks more like a spiral. From two dimensions, a spiral looks like a circle—it feels like you are going round and round, stuck on the exact same problem.
If you find yourself dealing with "communication issues" six months after coaching, you might assume you haven't grown. Look closer: you aren't stuck on the old problem; you are confronting a higher-level version of it at a higher loop on the spiral.
How to set up an engagement for success
To protect your investment and avoid these pitfalls, use these strategies before you sign a contract:
Schedule exploratory sessions
If you aren't sure what kind of help you need, look for coaches who offer initial discovery calls. Use these conversations to test the waters with multiple practitioners. Here are four "green flags" to look for:
- Illuminating questions: Do they ask questions that help you see your situation from an angle you hadn't considered? Do they reflect your own thoughts back to you in a way that helps you recognize your own wisdom?
- Generous space: Do they give you space to talk and reflect, even if it takes you a moment to find the words?
- Curiosity over advice: Do they spend significantly more time asking questions and reflecting your thoughts than giving pre-packaged advice?
- Clarity: Can they articulate a crisper, more accurate description of your goal at the end of the call than you were able to express at the start?
Clarify expectations upfront
Before committing, establish clear answers to these core questions:
- What needs to be different? Define success in concrete behavioral terms (e.g., "I want to stop avoiding tough feedback conversations with my team," rather than "I want to be more confident").
- How will we measure progress? Decide early how you will evaluate whether the work is having an impact—whether through self-assessment, behavioral milestones, or direct feedback from your peers.
- What is the capacity commitment? Ensure you have the time and energy to do the actual work between calls, which is where real transformation occurs.
Am I the right coach for you?
I specialize in working with tech leaders and engineering teams—specifically through the lens of compassionate, effective leadership. Clients typically reach out to me in two scenarios:
- When stepping into a new leadership role: You’ve taken on a broader role and realize that the technical skills that got you here won't be enough to help you succeed at the next level.
- When scaling high-performing team leads: You want to give newly promoted leads the support, collaboration tools, and self-awareness they need to thrive right out of the gate.
If you're navigating a transition like this and want to see if coaching is your right next move, let’s schedule an exploratory conversation. No pitch, no pressure—just space to figure out where you are and where you want to go.
If you are considering coaching, but I'm not the right fit, please reach out anyway--I know a lot of amazing coaches and I'd love to connect you with someone who can help.